Friday, February 27, 2009

I Gotta Right to Sing the Blues



Billie's version * of I Gotta Right To Sing the Blues was waxed on April 20,1939 for Commodore Records.

Billie's singing here typifies all that I love about the early years of her recording career; when speaking of her voice/tone as a trumpet this is not to take away from her humanity - she conveys the lyric sentiment perfectly but she brings to it the beauty of something purely musical. You can feel the blues for her but you can enjoy the ride as you accept that certain things in life are a given.
Where most singers would have "torched it up" with Billie you've got a subtler resignation that doesn't deny the pain - as if to say, "Life is a bitch - so, what else is new? I gotta find a way to live with it."
While the rhythm section lays down the beat in Basie style, heart-beat SOLID (one can imagine the strums of guitarist Jimmy McLin springing OFF the beat, buoyant, like Freddie Greene) Billie floats over it all like a golden cloud.
To quote drummer Specs Powell;
"She was one of the first singers that did not emote, no bouncing around, sang very quietly, snapped right hand, holding it close to her side. Snapped her fingers and tapped her feet very quietly, head tilted slightly to one side. The opposite to most jazz singers [of that time], who seemed to be choreographed. Her whole attitude was very cool."

The song has a wonderful stoptime bit at the end of a verse; she sings on beats 1 and three with band answering on 2 and 4 "All I SEE...FOR...ME...IS...MIS...ER...Ree-EEE!" and when they all lock back in to the solid time it's total swinging joy.

Frankie Newton with Billie at the session



A fine addition the record is Tab Smith's wail of a solo on alto sax; I would have personally preferred someone like Lester Young or even Kermit Scott on tenor or Irving Fazola on clarinet, but I must admit that Smith's rather ornate 20's style glide upward gives a nice contrast to Billie's even swing.
To my ears, the high point of the record is Frankie Newton's muted trumpet obbligato
entwining Billies vocal. The more I hear it the more I'm amazed at the choice of notes that seemed to push Billie's phrases to the fore rather than merely ornament.
Newton was an anomaly, more of a Miles Davis for the swing era, with minimal lyric solos.
"Frank" as he preferred to be called, made an auspicious debut with Bessie Smith in the early 30's but virtually dropped out of the recording scene by the mid 40's; apparently his independent spirit was at odds with the music business. An avid reader, and painter who loved to play tennis he nevertheless continued to play the odd gig in Boston and remained a legend to those who recalled him. Jazz writer Nat Hentoff befriended Newton in his youth and relates how the older, athletic, father-figure walked protectively behind him and his girfriend through a dicey neighborhood to make sure he wasn't "jumped".


Frankie Newton with Sidney Bechet


The band for the session was the house band for the newly opened Cafe Society Uptown club on 58th Street between Park and Lexington in Manhattan. Barney Josephson, a jazz lover, was the son of Latvian immigrants, and had witnessed better treatment of black performers in Europe. He opened the club, partly to provide an integrated environment and also to showcase black performers as well as cabaret and comedy. It was Josephson who introduced Billie to her most famous song "Strange Fruit" - the thinly veiled portrayal of racist lynching in the south. The irony is that it was recorded at the very-same session as "I Gotta Right..." and would lead Billie down a very different road.
I would agree she became typecast in the following years as a "hard-luck" tragic chanteuse as much for this song as for the sordid details of her growing addiction to heroin and abusive men. Ironically (a situation much like Lester Young's), as her voice deteriorated, she was able to make more records under her own name - it always saddens me that so many listeners are ONLY familiar with the latter-day (of the 50's and late 40's) recordings and have no inkling of the golden-toned Billie.


Finally a word of praise should go out to the composer/melodist Harold Arlen and lyricist Ted Koehler who wrote "I Gotta Right to Sing the Blues". The stunning array of melodies written by Arlen include Over the Rainbow, Let's Fall In Love, Stormy Weather, Get Happy, I've Got the World On a String, One For My Baby, Come Rain or Come Shine among others!
No accident that Arlen was the son of a Jewish cantor who also loved secular music; especially operatic singers like Enrico Caruso and John McCormack. Harold Arlen stepped beyond his family phonograph and enveloped himself in the sounds of ragtime, jazz and the powerful blues of Bessie Smith - Billie Holiday's prime influence along with Louis Armstrong.

Harold Arlen >




For a fascinating in-depth comparison of Billie's "I Gotta Right..." with Louis Armstrong's equally wonderful take from 1934, see Lori Burns' Feeling the Style: Vocal Gesture and Musical Expression in Billie Holiday, Bessie Smith, and Louis Armstrong.

* Billies "I Gotta Right .." can be found by scrolling down to the bottom of the link page - next to The Complete Commodore recordings.

13 comments:

Trombonology said...

This afternoon in the car, I was listening to William, as the Count affectionately called her, doing "Trav'lin' Light," accompanied by, (of all aggregations) Paul Whiteman's Orchestra ... and I was thinking, as I always do when I hear her, That girl has perfect instincts. 'Cos that's what I think it was with Billie – pure instinct. She had a gift, she was a genius ... and she just knew what to do.

I think it's a darn shame that both (the albeit profoundly important) "Strange Fruit" and the hard luck gal image have become so prominent in the collective understanding of Billie. There was a lot of humor and playfulness in her approach and the subsequent records – along with a lot of other marvelous stuff, which deserves equal attention. Her "Blues" – undeniably, though – is so genuine; you have a sense that the performance came from experience. For my dough, nobody sang the blues like Billie, Louis and Jack Teagarden, the last of whom, I know you know, claimed the Arlen-Koehler gem as his theme.

Yeah, I wouldn't have chosen altoist Smith for that date (a little too gabby for my taste), but he shows more restraint than usual here and makes a nice statement. Very happy to find you singing Frankie Newton's praises; his work hasn't gotten the attention, among the masses, that it deserves. Economy and an intriguing tone – your Miles comparison is most apt.

Just a terrific study of a record, a singer, a song and a composer.

Tom the Piper's Son said...

Elizabeth -
I think of the blog you once wrote about hearing Billie's "I Hear Music" - a prime example of the joy she could spread. Things like "Now They Call It Swing", "When You're Smiling",all of those little numbers she did with Teddy Wilson (and yes, even Whiteman!) et al; a little more than 2 minutes in some cases, and one or two choruses from Billie, Lester, and the rest changed a lot lives I'm sure. Mine too.

Glad to hear you've heard enough of Frankie newton to be on a similar wavelength about him - i shouldn't be surprised :)

Tom the Piper's Son said...

I've been enjoying "Miss Brown To You" very much of late. Again, that Louis-like-trumpet vocal with just enough gravel to the sweetness. That little bit of Benny Goodman in the beginning and him together with the very brash Mr.Eldridge in the send out chorus also floors me....

http://searchservice.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=sitesearch.results&type=Music&qry=Miss%20Brown%20to%20You&submit=Search&orig=music_home_search

Trombonology said...

GREAT record! Ben Webster as well as Jazz get in a little fine obbligato work, too. I had to dig out my Teddy Wilson disc to refresh myself on who was playing guitar – John Truehart, who worked, for a time, with Chick Webb; nice rhythm. That whole session, in fact, is marvelous – "I Wished on the Moon"; "What a Little Moonlight Can Do" and "A Sunbonnet Sue" being the other sides. Goodman cut out before the last record was made; he'd contributed beautifully already, though.

Tom the Piper's Son said...

Great session all around, that. Love the clip on What A Little Moonlight.....
Have you read "I Wished on the Moon" the Billie bio by Donald Clarke. This is most absorbing and thorough bio of her I've read...saying a lot when so much of her life is hard to take.

Trombonology said...

Yup; read Wished when it came out – marvelous book, despite the fact that, as you say, many of the details of her life are difficult to take. My sis and I were walking Nelson today and somehow found ourselves on the subject of Billie shooting up her dog. That poor woman was so screwed up ... and yet she created some incredibly potently beautiful stuff – much of which, we must assume, had its interpretative origins in her rotten life.

Matthew H Camp said...

Digging this tune. Thanks for writing out the changes for me.

The subtlety of the changes, especially the D>C#>C on top of the F chord sequence, is a time capsule to an earlier age of cool swing.

Tom the Piper's Son said...

Elizabeth -
Boy, life gets complicated when one's dog is "on the stuff" too. There was probably some growling when it was Billie's turn to fix.
Seriously, it had probably gotten to the point where the dog was only "person" to be trusted.

As unsparing as the book was regarding Billie's life it was very informative about the peripheral people and music as well. I think Billie was happier being "one of the guys" as it were, meaning a part of the musical whole and not the sole focus.

Tom the Piper's Son said...

Matt -
Glenn and I did a sax and bass duet of it last night at the Paisley and it sounded good - although we didn't have time to work out the "punchy chromatic climb"! Look forward to our version. The floating over of the melody line of C#'s (concert) into C's from bar 4 to 5 "I've got a right to hang around" just kills me - there's something cool and sensual about it.
That Arlen guy had some great changes going....

Anonymous said...

[url=http://community.bsu.edu/members/buy+online+Viagra.aspx]Viagra on line no prescription[/url]

[url=http://eterporno.ru/prostitutki-g-hmelnickiy.php]проститутки г хмельницкий[/url]
[url=http://eterporno.ru/pamyatnik-prostitutke-praga.php]памятник проститутке прага[/url]
[url=http://pc.eterporno.ru/index.php]интимсити ру сайт[/url]
[url=http://pc.eterporno.ru/blyadi-piter-vhod.php]бляди питер вход[/url]

[url=http://pv.eterporno.ru/trans-intim-dosug.php]транс интим досуг[/url]
[url=http://pv.eterporno.ru/znakomstva-g-usinsk.php]знакомства г усинск[/url]
[url=http://px.eterporno.ru/index.php]интим услуги барнаул[/url]
[url=http://px.eterporno.ru/mamba-sayt-znakomstv-samyy-populyarnyy.php]мамба сайт знакомств самый популярный[/url]
[url=http://px.eterporno.ru/telefon-seks-znakomstva.php]телефон секс знакомства[/url]

[url=http://pz.eterporno.ru/znakomstva-vzlomat.php]знакомства взломать[/url]
[url=http://pz.eterporno.ru/tolstye-blyadi-moskvy.php]толстые бляди москвы[/url]

Anonymous said...

The writer of tomclohessy.blogspot.com has written a superior article. I got your point and there is nothing to argue about. It is like the following universal truth that you can not disagree with: User friendly and power user friendly are opposite ends of the scale. I will be back.

Anonymous said...

dating hot moms [url=http://loveepicentre.com/]larry birkenhead and anna dating[/url] dating flowers http://loveepicentre.com/ free single dating service

Anonymous said...

low fat diet facts [url=http://usadrugstoretoday.com/products/viagra-plus.htm]viagra plus[/url] reattaching nerves after prostate removal http://usadrugstoretoday.com/products/coreg.htm aniscen medicine http://usadrugstoretoday.com/products/xtz--energy-booster-.htm
sydney uni public health [url=http://usadrugstoretoday.com/products/phenergan.htm]phenergan[/url] vaginal during intercourse [url=http://usadrugstoretoday.com/products/weight-loss.htm]diabetes chromium[/url]